Artificial intelligence (AI) is speedily altering the globe, and the field of intellectual residence regulation is no exception. AI is getting used to build new products and solutions and services, automate tasks, and even generate inventive information. This raises a variety of issues for mental property law, which is built to shield the rights of creators and innovators.
1 of the largest challenges is identifying who owns the mental assets rights to AI-created functions. For instance, if an AI method results in a new tune, who owns the copyright to that track? The particular person who made the AI process? The human being who programmed the method? The man or woman who owns the facts that the technique was skilled on? There is no distinct respond to to this question, and it is likely to be the subject of significantly litigation in the many years to appear.
One more problem is how to safeguard intellectual house legal rights in the facial area of AI-enabled infringement. AI techniques can be applied to build counterfeit items, to automate the method of copyright infringement, and to even create pretend information. This helps make it extra tricky for creators to guard their work and to enforce their mental home rights.
The rise of AI also raises queries about the foreseeable future of patent law. Patents are designed to protect innovations, but it is not clear irrespective of whether AI-generated innovations can be patented. For illustration, if an AI process invents a new drug, who can patent that drug? The individual who designed the AI procedure? The particular person who programmed the process? The human being who owns the info that the technique was educated on? Yet again, there is no crystal clear respond to to this issue, and it is most likely to be the issue of substantially litigation in the yrs to appear.
The rise of AI is having a profound impression on mental house regulation. It is generating new challenges for creators and innovators, and it is forcing us to rethink the way we protect mental property. It is very likely that the law will need to evolve in order to continue to keep rate with the speedy growth of AI.
In addition to the difficulties described higher than, AI is also increasing new thoughts about the role of intellectual assets in a world where devices are more and more capable of producing and innovating. Some have argued that AI will sooner or later make mental property law out of date, as devices will be ready to build and distribute will work without the need of the require for human intervention. Some others have argued that AI will truly make intellectual property regulation more significant, as it will build new chances for innovation and creative imagination. It is much too early to say which of these sights will eventually prevail, but it is obvious that AI is acquiring a profound affect on intellectual residence legislation.
This report was assisted by an AI motor and reviewed, simple fact-checked and edited by our editorial staff.
All the buzz about crypto artwork raises concerns about fraud and counterfeiting in an unregulated market place. NFT authorities Joshua Chu and Julian So explain how electronic ownership tokens defend the creator and operator from such threats
As virtual belongings produced a comeback in 2021, just one new edition in the spotlight was non-fungible tokens (NFTs). Crypto sceptics generally argue there is no tangible house connected with NFTs, so they are just hype with no benefit.
On the other hand, with acknowledgment that intangible property these as mental property have been traded for hundreds of years, the actual missed difficulty is whether or not traders are knowledgeable of the underlying worth of the asset they purchase, particularly, ascertaining what they are shopping for and its price, with thanks diligence.
Joshua Chu
NFTs are not interchangeable, and one of a kind as a collectible electronic or actual physical item. They can be a single version or a restricted range to ascribe a rarity worth.
The most common dilemma with NFTs early on was storage place, in a centralised or decentralised server. Fundamental smart contracts in NFTs are basically pc codes that facilitate the settlement of a sale and purchase transaction, together with the payment of fees, but do not convey any authorized rights.
Unless of course the NFT can take the variety of a hybrid wise deal, with certain organic-language conditions created into the code, it can’t be considered a lawfully binding arrangement.
Devoid of purchasers and subsequent sellers obtaining a foundation of assessing honest benefit of the underlying asset to their NFTs, worth appreciably risks fluctuating unpredictably, as its foundation is centered fully on emotion.
Electronic possession tokens
Julian So
A digital possession token (DOT) is developed by utilising blockchain and NFT technologies instruments accessible on blockchain platforms, with a unique identifier to replicate the electronic ownership title to a tangible or an intangible asset.
A DOT embeds legally binding ownership documentation into its metadata and secures this kind of metadata on a blockchain.
The underlying asset of a DOT will typically be accompanied by the following paperwork:
A sale and buy arrangement obtaining the fundamental asset from the owner
A representation from such owner that it is the authorized and advantageous operator of these underlying asset, and has the electrical power to make the sale
A transfer deed that transfers the fundamental asset to the holder of the DOT
A 3rd-bash unbiased valuation or appraisal report on the fundamental asset, the place suitable and
All related legal paperwork.
Consequently, DOTs address the concern with most NFTs, particularly, determining what the purchaser is in truth buying, assignment of legal legal rights, and ascertaining worth of the underlying asset.
DOTs will also satisfy requirements by regulators when it comes to virtual belongings.
This was echoed by the Financial Authority of Singapore in 2022, which stated: “Blockchain, tokenisation and cryptography can be deployed collectively to permit the fractionalisation of large-benefit property and monetisation of formerly un-monetised belongings. This will in flip aid to unlock new economic benefit, increase monetary inclusion, and help far more seamless and successful provision of economic companies.”
Whilst regulators have expressed fears more than “blank digital assets” (digital property with nothing within), they have also revealed fascination in DOTs.
Some DOTs will consist of metaverse integration features and augmented truth features. For instance, envision having an antique or portray with a museum curator explaining how it is legitimate, its historical past and historic benefit, all designed into the metadata of the DOT.
The gains of DOTs will consequently carry ahead, the two in the virtual and actual physical realities.
For illustration, a hybrid DOT, also acknowledged as a H-DOT, will consist of the next authorized devices embedded into its metadata and secured on a trusted blockchain: sale and order settlement evidence or guarantee of ownership transfer of sub-licence detailing holder rights and impression, online video, audio or other file.
H-DOT proprietors can verify ownership and/or licensing legal rights from the authorized files minted into them. A QR code is normally employed pointing to all related lawful documents.
Authorized legal rights
A DOT can solve the issue of unauthorised copying of NFTs as a lawful agreement by specifying the intended contracting functions. It is made up of conditions of ownership, licence and legal rights, and available authorized recourses if 3rd parties breach any of them.
Now, under prevalent law, the basis of any agreement features the pillars of privity of agreement, and offer you, acceptance and thought.
Even though NFT bootleggers will be equipped to copy pure codes containing hyperlinks to in which a digital asset is saved, the identical simply cannot be finished against a DOT simply because of the prevailing contract legislation principle.
For example, the doctrine of privity of deal provides that a person simply cannot purchase and implement rights below a agreement if not a celebration, and a man or woman who is not a get together cannot be produced liable underneath it. This doctrine is enshrined in The Hong Kong Contracts (Legal rights of 3rd Parties) Ordinance (cap 623).
Consequently, an NFT bootlegger are not able to basically clone a DOT, as they have no privity to the authorized instrument in the DOT. Accordingly, only a lawful operator of DOTs can enforce their lawful rights.
Conversely, contracts that are embedded into the tokens of DOTs can also address the problem of correct provide, acceptance and consideration.
In the earlier, mental residence rights to NFTs were being at periods only an afterthought, as there was no assignment of these legal rights at the time of issuing the first NFT. Challenges occur when mental residence rights are basically “granted” retrospectively through centralised phrases and circumstances deal disorders of offer, acceptance and thing to consider for such intellectual residence legal rights are not present.
It must be mentioned that makes an attempt by a lot of NFT issuers to rectify earlier troubles of not assigning rights by amending and issuing a centralised set of phrases and situations betrays the really idea of blockchain, which enshrines decentralisation.
Thought is also vital in which 1 side offers up anything in return for an expected return, and should really comprise the subsequent requirements:
By means of negotiation where by terms are laid out by both equally functions
Mutual exchange attained, where by both functions gain anything and
The exchange have to be of value in some way (it is not the court’s spot to decide the value).
As these types of, it are unable to be explained there exists correct thing to consider of a proper that is retrospectively assigned to a purchaser. Prior attempts by NFT assignments to retrospectively assign mental house legal rights to token holders may possibly have finished up ineffective owing to failure to comply with basic requirements for deal and thought.
Lawfully talking, the only way for good ratification of a variety of past NFT initiatives is to only re-situation tokens with all the appropriate new contracts embedded. Having said that, this is logistically difficult mainly because numerous tokens have previously been assigned by way of secondary income, the place the original difficulty of privity agreement will return to haunt new NFT holders.
Only the serious owner of a DOT will be equipped to get the essential authorized action, as stipulated in the lawful deal, against breach of that owner’s electronic possession legal rights. DOTs can adequately secure token holder’s rights less than Hong Kong rules and prevalent regulation.
Seamless and paperless
One of the biggest grievances against the lawful occupation is how environmentally unfriendly it has become. Not only is paper transaction unsustainable, it also usually takes time. A usual paper transaction will experience significant lag time if heading by means of legal professionals planning applicable transaction files – occasionally using months to finish.
The existing state of a secondary market for untokenised assets is akin to stock marketplace trades in the ’90s just before the web, where by a broker is named to manually complete a transaction, as opposed to working with an automated market maker currently. It is very doubtful that traders would settle for a entire day’s delay for trade in today’s inventory market.
By tokenising property into DOTs, secondary trade can be transacted digitally, acquiring the two the commercial plans of swift transaction and sustainability targets. The DOT to commercial papers is consequently akin to an automatic current market maker, enabling far bigger transaction scale.
The authorized framework to empower seamless, instantaneous and paperless residence transactions in Hong Kong presently exists, discovered in the Conveyancing and Home Ordinance (cap 219), Land Titles Ordinance (cap 585, not yet in influence), and Electronic Transactions Ordinance (cap 553).
But despite passage back again in 2004, the Land Titles Ordinance has stalled owing to competing pursuits of paper-dependent conveyancers and technological know-how resistance.
The end result, sadly, is that conveyancing transactions even now have to have significant time to finish, averaging no significantly less than six months, whilst parties are at the mercy of current market uncertainties, with the slightest change in markets seeding probable disputes.
The introduction of DOT technological innovation is the previous piece of the puzzle that will ultimately propel conveyancing in Hong Kong to the modern-day age.
By seamless and paperless transactions, not only will Hong Kong’s financial state benefit from enhanced transaction quantity with plentiful completion. Billings can also most likely, a single day, become a passive and computerized money stream, freeing legal professionals to focus on lawyering once again, alternatively of becoming sure by billing hrs.
Joshua Chu is team main chance officer at blockchain companies Coinllectibles, Marvion and XBE. Julian So is group CEO at XBE in Hong Kong
We are delighted to announce that, for the next year in a row, Legal professional Dmitriy Borshchak, the founder of the Legislation Office of Dmitriy Borshchak, has been chosen as a 2023 Ohio Increasing Star Tremendous Attorney.
COLUMBUS, Ohio, April 2, 2023 /PRNewswire-PRWeb/ — What is an Ohio Tremendous Law firm?
Superb concern. Tremendous Lawyer is a extremely highly regarded nationwide score service that has been about for about 70 decades. Legal professionals from all unique types of methods are provided, from legal legislation to appellate practice. Just about every calendar year, the prime attorneys in just about every observe space are honored with the title of either Tremendous Attorney or Rising Star.
The range method starts with nominations. Lawyers are asked to place forth the names of their friends that they experience should have this distinctive honor. The lawyers who are nominated by their peers are then evaluated, through independent third get-togethers, applying the Super Lawyers’ patented procedure. This method encapsulates scores spanning twelve groups, which involve points like encounter, honors or awards, special licenses, and settlements.
Just after that, the attorneys who have the ‒highest position totals from steps 1 and two– are evaluated by peers in just their particular practice spot. Lastly, attorneys representing a various array of little, medium, and significant companies are chosen as both Growing Stars or Super Legal professionals. To give you an perception into how remarkably selective this method is, only 2.5{c024931d10daf6b71b41321fa9ba9cd89123fb34a4039ac9f079a256e3c1e6e8} of the attorneys nominated turn into Mounting Stars, and only 5{c024931d10daf6b71b41321fa9ba9cd89123fb34a4039ac9f079a256e3c1e6e8} come to be Tremendous Attorneys. The requirements to be a Soaring Star is even additional selective, as only attorneys who are 40 several years outdated or youthful or have been training considerably less than 10 many years can be picked as a Growing Star.
Who is Attorney Dmitriy Borshchak?
Attorney Borshchak, the founder of the Law Office environment of Dmitriy Borshchak, started his foray into Domestic Relations in 2016 after graduating from Money University here in Columbus, Ohio, and effectively passing the Ohio Condition Bar Examination. At any time the entrepreneur, he set his sights on opening his individual business, and as they say, the rest is background.
What sets Attorney Borshchak apart from other divorce lawyers is his innate capability to devise and execute a strategic program to acquire your plans. From the starting of a scenario, he is ready to established the phase to give his purchasers the ideal odds of accomplishment and reduce their publicity to possibility. He will work intently with his associates, cultivating an setting that focuses on the greatest amount of execution of almost everything from the to start with pleading to the final working day of demo.
This is why he has been able to correctly litigate significant asset divorces, little one custody conditions, and each spousal and youngster guidance matters. He has consumers all over the state – from Delaware County, Franklin County, and even Erie County. His results speak for them selves, which is why he has been honored as a 2023 Super Lawyer.
Curious about what the Legislation Place of work of Dmitriy Borshchak can do for you?
If you are looking for counsel that can give you the finest achievable activity prepare to secure yourself during a divorce, or if you need to have anyone in your corner in a custody fight, speak to the Regulation Office of Dmitriy Borshchak today.
Our family members regulation lawyers are completely ready to struggle along with you each and every step of the way and do our complete very best to protected a effective consequence. Get in touch with us currently for a no cost consultation and see what a two-time Super Law firm can do for you.
Pull Quotation
“Shoppers come to us when they require success, and we deliver. Currently being selected as a Mounting Star Tremendous Attorney for the second year in a row is a testomony to our dedication to excellence and the accomplishment of our customers.” – Attorney Dmitriy Borshchak
Welcome to Bloomberg Law’s Wake Up Phone, a day by day rundown of the top rated news for attorneys, regulation corporations, and in-property counsel.
The Colorado Supreme Court approved a new civil course of action rule that will enable some non-lawyers get accredited by means of a paraprofessional program to exercise regulation in particular loved ones relations issues. The new rule aims to improve accessibility to legal representation in domestic legislation conditions, the state’s judicial division mentioned in a statement. Colorado joins Arizona, Minnesota, Oregon, and Utah, which have all issued some form of limited license for non-lawyers to observe regulation. (Colorado Judicial Branch)
The Institute for the Development of the American Legal Process is operating on recommendations to aid states acquire lawful paraprofessional courses, its director of unique projects, Michael Houlberg, states in a new Converse Justice podcast. (Authorized Speak Network)
Ice Miller’s gross revenues eeked down .6{c024931d10daf6b71b41321fa9ba9cd89123fb34a4039ac9f079a256e3c1e6e8} to $247.5 million in 2022, as offer get the job done slowed and a group of its litigators moved to yet another business, according to a report based mostly on early facts. Indianapolis-established Ice Miller stated bigger travel charges, non-lover salaries, and inflation dragged on its typical earnings per equity spouse, which fell 14.5{c024931d10daf6b71b41321fa9ba9cd89123fb34a4039ac9f079a256e3c1e6e8}. (American Attorney)
Leaders of some Significant Law firms say they’re not extremely anxious about double-digit financial gain drops right after the soaring earnings and profit gains of 2022. (American Attorney)
Attorneys, Legislation Companies
A new Florida legislation championed by Governor Ron DeSantis tends to make it more difficult to sue insurance organizations, organizations and property entrepreneurs. (Miami Herald) Massive Florida-centered plaintiffs business Morgan & Morgan told its attorneys that the regulation displays that insurers are “the enemy.” (Florida Politics) (The Insurance provider) (Above The Legislation)
Gals best legal professionals of five major Washington athletics groups which include Important League Baseball’s Nationals, the NFL’s Commanders, and the Countrywide Basketball League’s Wizards, amid others, talked recently about their work and troubles they’ve faced. ABC 7 News)
The Securities and Trade Commission charged a Texas resident, his New York lawyer and law organization, between other people, in three alleged strategies to defraud at the very least 28 investors of additional than $8.4 million. (SEC.gov)
Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders hired The Lanier Legislation Company to litigate the state’s statements towards Fb mum or dad Meta Platforms, Inc. (PR Newswire)
Laterals, Moves, In-residence
Gibson Dunn explained it recruited previous Apple Inc. senior counsel Christopher Rosina, who was principal architect of the Apple iphone maker’s world wide privacy compliance application. Rosina joins Gibson Dunn as of counsel in New York in its privacy, cybersecurity, and info innovation, synthetic intelligence, and automatic techniques practice groups. (GibsonDunn.com)
Transatlantic organization Womble Bond Dickinson extra fintech legal professional Howard Herndon as a company and securities lover in Nashville, Tennessee. Concentrated on the digital transaction field, he comes from Frost Brown Todd wherever he led the payments business group. (Womble Bond Dickinson)
Greenspoon Marder introduced in civil and white collar prison litigator Marie L. Wrighten as a labor and employment partner in Los Angeles. She comes from Lewis Brisbois Bisgaard & Smith. (GMLaw.com)
The Rockefeller Foundation stated its board of trustees verified its performing common counsel due to the fact May perhaps 2022, Erica Guyer, to the long term function of typical counsel and company secretary. (RockefellerFoundation.org)
Cleveland, Ohio-dependent Utilized Industrial Technologies, Inc. employed Jon Ploetz as vice president, basic counsel, and secretary. He succeeds Fred D. Bauer who lately retired. Ploetz joins from Harsco Corporation, company of environmental remedies for industrial and specialty waste streams, the place he was vice president, assistant GC, and assistant corporate secretary. (Applied.com)
Mississippi-centered Huntington Ingalls Industries, Inc. promoted in-residence lawyer Julie Jarrell Gresham to vice president and chief counsel of the company’s Ingalls Shipbuilding division. (Hii.com)
We hear this thirty day period from highly skilled IP litigator Julie Katz on the COVID-19 pandemic, altering attitudes to civility in IP regulation and other developments shaping the occupation in 2023.
When we final spoke in 2021, you explained observing an raise in ‘uncivil conduct’ by IP lawyers. How has this been a detriment to helpful lawful advocacy in the sector?
The seemingly increasing degrees of incivility in the profession typically impacts authorized advocacy in a damaging method. What ordinarily transpires is that conflict concerning firms gets conflict among the advocates. In its place of focusing on the strengths and weaknesses of the situation, lawyers concentrate on bullying or intimidation litigation strategies.
This behaviour usually happens through the discovery period of a case, foremost to much more movement exercise about issues not germane to the merits of the circumstance. Clients finish up paying bigger legal professional costs for having to battle about discovery issues that are, normally, if not needless. Settlement conversations turned far more hard in which to engage.
In trademark scenarios, creativeness in resolving conflict for consumers’ added benefits is a essential component to settlement. Nevertheless, when the scenario goes from the probability of confusion problems to a collection of senseless motions, a company’s motivation to settle may be diminished.
Does the IP sector still battle with this, or has there been a change back again in the direction of civility?
I am grateful that in excess of the earlier pair of years, I have experienced significantly less and a lot less uncivil carry out by opposing counsel in litigation. It could be that the pandemic has altered attorney sights of consumer priorities and their very own own priorities.
Settling a scenario, which is usually in the greatest interest of the conflicting parties, indicates remaining focused on the precise company concerns that are in a position to be settled to guard buyers from remaining confused. Trying to keep the functions engaged in settlement negotiations to come to a meaningful resolution of the issues lifted comes with each other a great deal sooner when legal professionals are not clouding the content company concerns with private jabs or frivolous motion practice made largely to elevate the expenses of the scenario.
Just one factor you identified as contributing to incivility was a lack of sufficient authorized mentorship. Has there been any development in this place?
I am looking at an improve of mentorship packages, which I consider is encouraging the system. Regulation corporations and authorized organisations, at the non-public and condition stage, are participating in more powerful pushes for mentoring.
Some organisations have default assignments of an expert legal professional with a considerably less professional legal professional. Some request for volunteers. Nevertheless, both way, my knowledge in excess of the previous couple of a long time is that the all round point out of perform is a lot more civil. Advocating really hard for your client’s legal rights does not require incivility. In fact, when my opponent is a skilled advocate, I uncover that the regard level is heightened and we get to resolution quicker.
What other developments have you witnessed? Has the lifting of pandemic-era constraints allowed companies to establish out their IP portfolios?
Even during the pandemic, it appeared that sure industries had been in a position to dive deep into their IP portfolios and stay concentrated on defense and enforcement, together with defensive steps. The silence of many field distractions or interventions authorized for singular interior critique in quite a few corporations so we did not knowledge a downtrend in productivity.
Advocating tough for your client’s rights does not demand incivility.
Absence of commuting challenges favoured this legal discipline, in my opinion. As pandemic-period limits are loosened, some judges are continuing to permit the overall flexibility that video standing conferences insert to everyone’s effectiveness and productiveness. It has been eye-opening and is shifting the earlier rigidity on in-human being conferences that could have to have hours of journey for 5 minutes of experience-to-deal with.
In-human being courtroom appearances are essential, but are now remaining weighed against the problem offered to the court. For example, a summary judgment oral argument is commonly far better suited for face-to-confront in the court with the judge, but much a lot less so for a short standing hearing to test that the scenario is moving ahead.
Has the emergence of new electronic property and AI plans introduced considerable transform to the sector?
Electronic assets in the character of video clip conferencing advancements have served the legal job – at minimum as far as I have knowledgeable in the past two a long time – for the greater. I have listened to from a range of judges on best practices for this variety of judicial conversation.
Julie Katz has around 30 yrs of working experience in the mental assets arena, performing intently with customers on each litigation and prosecution across quite a few systems, industries and customer marketplaces. Her exercise is focused on aligning her clients’ intellectual house portfolio with their overall small business strategy by identifying, preserving and maximising their IP rights. With a deep comprehension of IP law and enforcement strategies, a client-centred provider philosophy and a record of thriving litigation results on substantial-profile infringement conditions, Julie has acquired the tactical and nuanced insight that will allow her to rigorously shield her clients’ enterprise passions.
A Philadelphia decide on Wednesday dismissed a lawsuit submitted by the city’s law enforcement union that challenged a legislation banning some very low-amount site visitors stops.
The Fraternal Buy of Police Lodge 5, which represents about 6,100 officers, filed the accommodate much more than a year back, declaring the town was illegally preempting present point out law and asking a judge to declare the ordinance invalid. The FOP also contended the laws built Philadelphia less risk-free, and named Mayor Jim Kenney and Police Commissioner Danielle Outlaw as defendants.
Typical Pleas Court Decide Craig Levin dominated that how and when police carry out minimal site visitors stops are “matters of purely community concern” and that the mayor has discretion to determine how laws are enforced in the town.
John McNesby, president of the FOP, mentioned in a statement that the regulation “allows reckless drivers powering the wheel of unsafe autos, which eventually places the general public at-threat and in risk.” He claimed the union ideas to appeal.
The laws, which passed Metropolis Council, 14-2, in 2021 and took outcome a year back, classified 8 very low-degree traffic violations, these kinds of as driving with a destroyed bumper or a damaged headlight, as “secondary,” indicating they could not be the sole motive a driver was pulled about by law enforcement.
Philadelphia was the 1st major city to enact these kinds of a ban. Lawmakers and proponents stated the law aimed to deal with racial disparities in police stops and cut down on unwanted interactions amongst officers and motorists. Authorities were meant to deliver tickets for the infractions rather of pulling about motorists.
The ordinance was accompanied by an executive get that necessitates the Law enforcement Section to share in depth info and records about traffic stops.
Stops involved with the qualified violations dropped by 54{c024931d10daf6b71b41321fa9ba9cd89123fb34a4039ac9f079a256e3c1e6e8}, or almost 16,000, involving 2021 and 2022, in accordance to Councilmember Isaiah Thomas, the bill’s author. But an Inquirer assessment showed racial disparities involved with all those stops had been unchanged because the law’s implementation.
» Study Much more: Philadelphia’s driving equality law reduced targeted traffic stops but not racial disparities in its to start with year
In a statement Thursday, Thomas explained the laws has led Philadelphia law enforcement to prioritize targeted visitors stops for additional serious infractions and identified as the legislation a “national product for law enforcement reform and community progress.”
For the duration of a information meeting previously this month, he defended the legislation, saying it is lawfully sound and does not make the city less risk-free.
“Shame on any one who tries to say that for the reason that we’re combating for the plight of Black men and women that we’re trying to set ourselves in a situation to make the metropolis a lot more risky,” he stated.
The Mayor’s Office did not reply to requests for comment.
The variety of traffic stops in Philadelphia has dropped precipitously in latest several years. According to law enforcement figures, there were, on typical, about 330,000 car or truck stops annually involving 2015 and 2019. That range was more than halved in 2020 and 2021 amid the pandemic, with police pulling over about 150,000 motorists each of people years.
/cloudfront-us-east-1.images.arcpublishing.com/pmn/RRLTSNZWAVCSLFE5IVNACROQOQ.jpg?w=2000&resize=2000,1200&ssl=1 "Philly court tosses police union lawsuit over driving equality law")