The ER scanned her after a car accident. She was fine, but the bill was $17,000 : NPR

The ER scanned her after a car accident. She was fine, but the bill was $17,000 : NPR

Just after a car or truck incident, Frankie Prepare dinner went to the ER to make positive she failed to have a concussion. She walked out of the healthcare facility in the obvious. Then came the invoice.


It really is time now for our Healthcare Monthly bill of the Thirty day period. And Dr. Elisabeth Rosenthal is editor-in-chief of our lover Kaiser Health and fitness News and is with us to communicate about urgent treatment, crisis treatment and how these two web pages of remedy interact. Dr. Rosenthal, welcome back.

ELISABETH ROSENTHAL: Thanks. It is great to be below.

SUMMERS: So inform us. Who are we meeting currently?

ROSENTHAL: Right now we meet the Prepare dinner loved ones of Rome, Ga. The father is Russell Prepare dinner, and his daughter is Frankie, who’s a college or university freshman now. Just after Frankie was in a automobile accident, they identified out that just one substantial variance among urgent care and crisis place care is the dimension of the invoice. And that’s genuine for the very same client and the exact client criticism.

SUMMERS: Oh, gosh. This does not seem superior. KHN reporter Sam Whitehead frequented the Cooks. Let us listen to their tale.

SAM WHITEHEAD: Frankie Prepare dinner remembers final year’s motor vehicle incident in flashes. She was driving a buddy dwelling from higher school on a winding place road. She noticed standing h2o and tried out to gradual down but hydroplaned.

FRANKIE Cook: The motor vehicle flipped about three moments. We spun all-around and went off the aspect of this hill. And so my motor vehicle was on its side, and, like, the back again conclusion was crushed up into a tree.

WHITEHEAD: Frankie and her close friend had been wearing seatbelts when the car’s airbags deployed, so no person was critically harm when the police and Frankie’s dad Russell obtained there.

RUSSELL Cook dinner: All of the grown ups were variety of shocked that they have been Ok.

WHITEHEAD: But it appeared terrible more than enough.

R Prepare dinner: Oh, it seemed terrifying. Yeah. They have been fortunate to have just walked away.

WHITEHEAD: Frankie was wonderful other than for a little bit of a headache and a get worried she just could not shake.

F Cook dinner: I just was worried, since of the character of the wreck, that I experienced a concussion of some sort. And I experienced an AP exam two times afterwards, my AP physics exam. And so I was like, I you should not want to, you know, take that with a concussion.

WHITEHEAD: So the Cooks went to an urgent treatment clinic. Russell explained to a receptionist there that Frankie experienced been in a automobile incident and he’d like to have her checked out.

F Cook: And they claimed, oh, we will not consider 3rd-party insurance. And it produced no perception to me. And she advised me, like, three instances, we don’t take 3rd-celebration insurance policy. You have to go to the medical center for that.

WHITEHEAD: The closest ER was about a mile down the street and owned by the exact firm as the urgent treatment.

F Cook: They are all rather shut together. It can be so much less difficult to just go to the one particular that’s right there, that’s owned by the exact people today.

WHITEHEAD: Two CT scans came back again apparent – no concussion or other inside injuries. And Frankie was despatched household with recommendations to choose it straightforward for a few days. She passed her AP test, by the way. So Russell was stunned when he obtained a letter from the hospital’s attorney stating it was $17,000 for the ER go to.

R Cook: I was pissed, I mean, truly, you know, kind of up in arms. Why did I get a $17,000 invoice?

WHITEHEAD: Russell pushed the hospital for a breakdown of the monthly bill. There was a replicate $5,000 trauma evaluation cost, and Frankie was billed for a Stage IV ER pay a visit to, the second highest amount of severity.

R Cook: She walked in and walked out and was told to get some Tylenol, you know? So I just desired to know why was she billed as that mainly because I have got to spend for it.

WHITEHEAD: Russell under no circumstances received an remedy to that question, but he did get the double cost removed. He also does not have clarity on why Frankie couldn’t have just been noticed at the urgent treatment to rule out a concussion, particularly when other household users experienced been witnessed at that sort of clinic.

R Prepare dinner: Frankie’s grandmother was in a auto incident, went to the urgent treatment around her dwelling, was checked out – great – $200 monthly bill. That is variety of what I was anticipating.

WHITEHEAD: Russell suggests after insurance policies, he owes about $1,000 for Frankie’s ER check out. On information from an legal professional friend, he still has not paid even all these months later simply because he nonetheless has unanswered concerns about Frankie’s invoice. I am Sam Whitehead in Rome, Ga.

SUMMERS: Alright, Dr. Rosenthal. This raises some actually massive inquiries for me, far too. What occurred below with Frankie currently being turned away from urgent care?

ROSENTHAL: Very well, here’s the detail. Urgent care centers can transform people away. They’re not matter to a federal law termed EMTALA that claims crisis rooms have to see any person who reveals up regardless of their coverage or their ability to fork out. The regulation enables the urgent care facilities to be a good deal choosier. And this one particular chose not to take care of a person on the basis of the possibility of car insurance being involved. And let’s be clear right here, way too. The clinic didn’t say, we are not able to address your type of personal injury. They said, we would not address you for the reason that of your insurance coverage.

SUMMERS: So is that what the receptionist was speaking about when she mentioned 3rd-celebration insurance?

ROSENTHAL: Yeah. Persons have to have to know that if you have been in an accident, seriously, of any variety, even slipping in your possess bathtub, there’s a probability that your wellbeing insurance policies is going to try out to get yet another sort of insurance coverage – say, property or car – to pay out your medical expenditures initially. And whilst urgent care centers have contracts with health care insurers, acquiring home or automobile insurance plan to fork out up may well be a huge problem involving lawyers and delays. So they type of want to stay away from that.

SUMMERS: Okay. So the other detail that stuck out to me below is that this crisis home was just a mile away and owned by the identical company as the urgent care.

ROSENTHAL: Effectively, normally speaking, hospitals do use these omnipresent urgent treatment facilities to produce a kind of pipeline of referrals – you know, new clients they can ship to the healthcare facility. But I’m not sure you can invoke that sort of conspiracy in this certain scenario.

SUMMERS: So what should patients know about traveling to these two web sites?

ROSENTHAL: There are a few vital issues – initially, that the ER is probable to be exponentially far more highly-priced than urgent treatment. So attempt urgent care 1st. Also, in the ER, you’ll get much a lot more testing just mainly because you’re there, whether it is really absolutely wanted or not. So if an urgent care clinic indicates they are not able to handle you for regardless of what rationale and implies, oh, just go to the ER, check with in its place for a referral to a physician or a specialty clinic. You happen to be likely to help you save a complete good deal of funds.

SUMMERS: All ideal. That is some very good suggestions. Dr. Elizabeth Rosenthal, thank you for becoming here.

ROSENTHAL: Thanks for possessing me yet again.

SUMMERS: And if you have an outrageous or just puzzling health-related invoice, go to NPR’s Pictures website and notify us all about it.

Copyright © 2022 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our site phrases of use and permissions web pages at for even further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its ultimate form and may possibly be up-to-date or revised in the future. Precision and availability may possibly fluctuate. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.